The Importance of Addressing the Root Causes of Bank Failures

Current Regulations and Their Limitations

While current regulations, such as higher capital requirements, aim to mitigate risks, they fail to address the root causes of these failures. Defective risk governance, culture, and infrastructure are the real culprits behind these unfortunate events. To combat this issue, there is a growing call for the implementation of a risk management quality score (RMQS). Which will directly assess every bank’s risk management practices.

The Short-Term Focus of Many Institutions

Boards of directors and senior management often prioritize short-term earnings over long-term financial viability, leading to risky behavior. This shortsighted approach can have devastating consequences for both the banks and the wider economy. The quality of a firm’s risk culture, governance, and infrastructure determines the occurrence of risk events. Therefore, it is imperative to shift the focus towards a more comprehensive evaluation of risk management practices.

Benefits of a Risk Management Quality Score

A risk management quality score would serve as a powerful tool for improving risk management practices and reducing the number of bank failures. By assessing factors such as risk culture, governance, and infrastructure, banks can identify areas of weakness and implement necessary changes. This score would not only enable banks to better manage their risks but also provide regulators with a clear benchmark to evaluate their risk management practices.

Integrating RMQS in Key Operational Aspects

Furthermore, a risk management quality score should be utilized to set risk-based deposit insurance premiums, dividend policies, company growth, and management incentive compensation plans. By linking these important aspects to a bank’s risk management practices, there would be a direct incentive for banks to prioritize risk management over other activities. This would create a more robust risk management framework, ensuring the long-term financial viability of banks.

Learning from Other Industries

A similar rating system already exists in the pharmaceutical sector, known as Quality Management Maturity (QMM). This system has proven to be effective in reducing risks to the drug supply chain. By adopting a similar approach in the banking industry, we can learn from the successes of the pharmaceutical sector and apply them to our own unique challenges.

Theoretical Application: The Case of SVB

To illustrate the potential benefits of a risk management quality score, let’s take the example of a fictitious bank, SVB. SVB’s collapse could have been prevented if a rating system had been in place. By directly addressing market and liquidity risk exposures, the rating system would have prompted SVB to take necessary precautions and avoid its ultimate downfall. This demonstrates the power of a comprehensive risk management framework in preventing catastrophic failures.

Collaborative Implementation and Oversight

Implementing a risk management quality score would require a collaborative effort between banks, regulators, and industry experts. It is essential to establish clear guidelines and standards to ensure consistency and fairness across the industry. Additionally, regular assessments and audits should be conducted to track the progress and effectiveness of the rating system.

In conclusion, addressing the root causes of bank failures is of utmost importance in ensuring the stability and sustainability of the banking industry. The implementation of a risk management quality score provides a comprehensive framework to assess and manage risks effectively. By linking risk management practices to key aspects such as deposit insurance premiums and management incentives, banks will be incentivized to prioritize risk management. The comparison to the pharmaceutical sector’s rating system highlights the potential benefits of adopting a similar approach in the banking industry. Together, we can create a more resilient and secure financial system for the future.

Interested in speaking with our consultants? Click here to get in touch.